| Nombre | Equipo |
|---|---|
| Stanley Matthews | Blackpool |
| Bobby Moore | West Ham |
| Bill Foulkes | Manchester United |
| Bobby Charlton | Manchester United |
| Tom Finney | Preston North End |
| Ted Ditchburn | Tottenham |
| Eddie Baily | Nottingham Forest |
| Bert Williams | Wolverhampton |
| Jimmy Mullen | Wolverhampton |
| Billy Wright | Wolverhampton |
| Jimmy Dickinson | Portsmouth |
| Bill Eckersley | Blackburn Rovers |
| Gil Merrick | Birmingham City |
| Syd Owen | Luton Town |
| Nat Lofthouse | Bolton Wanderers |
| Ted Burgin | Leeds United |
| Ken Green | Birmingham City |
| Albert Quixall | Manchester United |
| Harry Hooper | Birmingham City |
| Colin McDonald | Burnley |
