| Total | Partidos | Victorias | Empates | Derrotas | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total | 323 | 139 | (43%) | 81 | (25%) | 103 | (32%) |
| Casa | 160 | 91 | (57%) | 39 | (24%) | 30 | (19%) |
| Fuera | 163 | 48 | (29%) | 42 | (26%) | 73 | (45%) |
| Item | Competición | Local | Visitante | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mayor victoria en casa | Major League Soccer 2021 | New York City FC | 6-0 | DC United |
| Major League Soccer 2022 | New York City FC | 6-0 | Real Salt Lake | |
| Mayor victoria fuera | Major League Soccer 2017 | Orlando City | 0-3 | New York City FC |
| Major League Soccer 2019 | FC Cincinnati | 1-4 | New York City FC | |
| Mayor derrota fuera | Major League Soccer 2017 | Toronto FC | 4-0 | New York City FC |
| Major League Soccer 2018 | NY Red Bulls | 4-0 | New York City FC | |
| Major League Soccer 2015 | LA Galaxy | 5-1 | New York City FC | |
| Major League Soccer 2019 | Toronto FC | 4-0 | New York City FC | |
| Mayor derrota en casa | Major League Soccer 2016 | New York City FC | 0-7 | NY Red Bulls |
